• About
  • Advanced Search
  • Browse Proceedings
  • Access Policy
  • Sponsor
  • Contact
  • Gallery Index
  • competing before the resource: resource-advantage theory and constitutive competition in the emerging space economy

    Paper ID

    108345

    authors

    • Ahmet Can Şenlik
    • Olcay Ölçen
    • Büşra Önler Çiğdem
    • Çağlar Karakurt

    company

    İstanbul Gelişim University

    country

    Türkiye

    year

    2026

    abstract

    The commercialization of space resources is accelerating faster than the theoretical frameworks required to explain it. Pre-market contracts for lunar helium-3, infrastructure partnerships targeting the lunar south pole, and competing national legal regimes indicate that firms are already engaged in competition. Yet no established theory explains the nature of this competition. Existing scholarship divides into two camps: techno-economic feasibility analyses assessing profitability, and governance studies examining property rights and commons regimes. Both are necessary, yet insufficient. What remains absent is a firm-level theory of competitive dynamics: a framework explaining how organizations build advantage and create markets where resources do not yet economically exist. This paper introduces Resource-Advantage Theory, a marketing-rooted theory of competitive dynamics, to the space resource context and activates a dimension of the theory that terrestrial applications have largely left dormant. Resource-Advantage Theory conceptualizes competition as an evolutionary, disequilibrium-generating process in which firms pursue comparative advantages in heterogeneous, imperfectly mobile resources and innovation is endogenous. Its institutional-economic foundation holds that resources are not natural givens but are constituted through human knowledge, technology, and organizational capability. In terrestrial markets this claim recedes into the background. In the space resource context, it becomes analytically central. Space resources currently exist as proto-resources: physically present but economically unconstituted. The lunar surface and underground represents the most immediate frontiers for this analysis, given its proximity, advancing resource characterization, and active commercial investment. Lunar water ice, helium-3, and regolith-derived metals are real substances, yet none satisfies the conditions for Resource-Advantage competition because no firm can produce a scalable commercial offering from them. The competitive race today is therefore not over resources, but over the conditions that will constitute them. This distinction has not been theorized at the firm-strategy level. Drawing on analogues from deep-sea mining governance, mineral reporting standards, and oil frontier licensing, the paper develops a three-stage competitive model: prospecting competition, constitutive competition, and Resource-Advantage competition. The model clarifies how firms first compete for informational and relational assets, then shape the legal and infrastructural parameters that define resources, and only subsequently engage in classical resource-based rivalry. The paper contributes an anticipatory framework that extends Resource-Advantage Theory to pre-commercial market conditions, addresses the theory's limited treatment of market-creation dynamics, integrates governance and firm strategy, and generates testable propositions regarding the competitive evolution of the emerging lunar economy.

    STATUS: waiting for script files to load